Creative Formats & Assets

Expanded Text Ads vs Responsive Display Ads: Two Formats From Two Different Eras

In short: These two rarely get confused in practice since they don't compete for the same inventory, but contrasting them is useful because they sit at opposite ends of Google's creative spectrum. Expanded Text Ads were a fixed, hand-written Search format that Google retired from new creation in mid-2022. Responsive Display Ads are a current, automatically assembled format built from images and text that runs across the Display Network and Gmail. One is dead and text-only; the other is active and multi-format. If you're building anything new, the ETA side of this pairing is a history lesson, not an option - the live decision is only ever what to build for Display, and that's RDA.

By the AdFlint research team · Fact-checked against current Google and Meta platform behavior · Last reviewed July 2026

Expanded Text Ads

Google's legacy fixed-copy search ad with three headlines and two descriptions, retired in favor of responsive search ads and no longer creatable.

For years this was the standard search unit, with headlines and descriptions you wrote and controlled exactly. Google stopped new creation and editing in mid-2022 and has since wound the format down, migrating advertisers to responsive search ads. If an old playbook references it, translate the copy into RSA assets instead. The recurring frustration is expecting the same line-by-line control, which RSAs deliberately do not offer.

Full definition

Responsive Display Ads

Google Display ads assembled automatically from uploaded images, logos, headlines, and descriptions, then resized to fit almost any slot on the network.

You provide assets and Google generates native, image, and text variations shaped to publisher inventory, which is why they reach far more placements than fixed-size banners. Use them as the default for Display and remarketing campaigns. The mistake is uploading low-effort assets and never checking previews, so auto-generated video and awkward crops run unseen; supply both landscape and square images and review the combinations.

Full definition

Side by side.

The differences that actually change what happens in your account.

	Expanded Text Ads	Responsive Display Ads
Status today	Retired - cannot create or edit, may still be serving in older accounts.	Active and the default responsive format for Display.
Network	Search results and search partners.	Display Network, apps, and Gmail.
Assets involved	Text only - three headlines, two descriptions, fixed order.	Images, logos, videos, headlines, and descriptions, auto-assembled.
Who assembles the final creative	You - the ad ran exactly as written.	Google - combinations are chosen per impression and placement.
Editability	None for existing ones, beyond pause or removal.	Fully editable anytime.
Why you'd encounter it now	Auditing a legacy account, not building anything new.	Setting up or optimizing a current Display or remarketing campaign.
Failure mode	Assuming you can still create one to match an old high performer.	Uploading assets in only one aspect ratio and losing eligibility for many placements.

What actually separates them.

ETA belongs to Search auctions matched by keyword and query; RDA belongs to Display and Gmail placements matched by page or app context and audience signals - they never compete for the same impression.

ETA is a closed, non-editable legacy format; RDA is an open, actively maintained format Google keeps expanding asset options for.

ETA has zero visual component; RDA is built around visual assets, with text as a supporting element - close to the opposite creative shape.

An ETA still running today reflects a decision made before mid-2022 that can't be revised; an RDA reflects your current asset choices and can be changed at any time.

There's no migration path from ETA to RDA since they were never the same job - ETA's replacement is RSA, both being Search text formats, while RDA has no legacy predecessor in this pairing since it was built for Display from the start.

Which one should you use?

Use Expanded Text Ads when

You're auditing an older account and see ETAs still listed as serving, and need to explain why they can't be edited.
You're archiving historical performance data before an old ETA is fully removed.
Someone asks why 'the old ad' can't just be tweaked like it used to be.
You're documenting account history and need to date creative changes around the mid-2022 cutoff.

Use Responsive Display Ads when

You're launching or managing a Display or remarketing campaign and need creative that adapts to many slot sizes.
You have photo or lifestyle assets and want native, image, and auto-generated video variations without manual resizing.
You want one Display ad group to reach the widest reasonable set of placements.
You're troubleshooting weak Display reach and suspect your creative isn't shaped to fit available inventory.

Common questions.

Is there any reason to compare Expanded Text Ads to Responsive Display Ads at all?

Mostly for orientation - they sit on opposite ends of Google's format spectrum, one a retired fixed Search format and the other an active auto-assembled Display format. If you're deciding what to build today, this pairing isn't really a choice, since ETA isn't buildable; the only live decision is what goes into an RDA for your Display campaign.

Did Responsive Display Ads replace Expanded Text Ads?

No, they replace different things. ETA's actual replacement is Responsive Search Ads, since both are Search text formats; RDA has always been a separate, Display-only format built around images and text together, not a Search succession product.

I found an old ETA still serving - should I convert it to a Responsive Display Ad?

Not directly - they run on different networks, so there's no straightforward conversion. If the ad group is a Search ad group, translate the ETA's copy into Responsive Search Ad assets; if you also want Display presence, that's a separate Display campaign built with RDA assets from scratch, typically including images you never needed for the ETA at all.

Or stop choosing between them.

AdFlint picks the setting, writes the ads, and keeps optimizing inside the Google and Meta accounts you already own.

Try AdFlint free See how it works

Related comparisons

All comparisons